Parliament Defeats Amendment to Ensure AI Compliance with Copyright Law

The UK Parliament has recently voted against a proposed amendment designed to guarantee compliance with copyright regulations for AI models. This decision came as part of the ongoing progress of the Data (Use and Access) Bill, which has become a focal point of contention among creatives and industry advocates.

Concerns Voiced by Industry Leaders

Many creatives, including notable authors such as Kazuo Ishiguro and Helen Fielding, had supported the amendment, which was initially introduced by cross-bench peer Baroness Beeban Kidron. Following the vote, Kidron expressed her dismay, emphasizing that the government’s proposed impact assessment is insufficient to address the needs of creators.

Industry Reactions

The Authors’ Licensing and Collecting Society (ALCS) labeled the outcome “disappointing.” Richard Combes, ALCS deputy chief executive, stated, “That Baroness Kidron’s amendments to the Data Bill, which would ensure AI companies operate in line with existing UK copyright law, were not adopted is disappointing but not the end of the fight for a fairer, more transparent approach regarding the use of copyright works by AI companies.” Combes further criticized the government’s approach, calling for greater acknowledgment of creators’ rights.

The Call for Licensing Solutions

Despite the setback, the ALCS remains committed to advocating for solutions that promote transparency and proper remuneration for authors. They are currently collaborating with organizations like the Copyright Licensing Agency (CLA) and Publishers’ Licensing Services (PLS) to explore viable licensing models for AI training that would benefit copyright holders.

A Legislative Journey

This amendment, which had previously garnered support in the House of Lords, was not included in the version passed by the House of Commons. On May 7, Liberal Democrat MP Victoria Collins attempted to reintroduce it, but faced a significant defeat, with a vote tally of 287 against 88.

Looking Ahead

The debate surrounding this issue indicates a growing urgency among creatives to ensure their rights are protected in the evolving landscape of AI technology. As the Data Bill moves forward, stakeholders continue to emphasize the importance of establishing frameworks that balance the interests of innovative technologies with the rights of creators.